Google AdWords V.S. Facebook Advertising

Jason Girdner
Jason has always been at the forefront of connecting companies with customers. Before car dealers had websites, he was helping them generate leads using an 800 number that could take a credit app over the phone. He followed that up with success in direct mail, auto loans and a new frontier: Social Media.

In early March, I had the pleasure of attending the CBT Conference in Atlanta GA and the PCG Companies training session prior to the conference. Much of the discussion in automotive digital marketing is starting to center around Google AdWords and the quality of website traffic that is being generated.

Over the past decade, we have measured our results on Google AdWords by looking at CPCBounce RatesImpression Share, and Click Through Rates. These simple metrics worked great when cars were flying off the shelf.

Over the past few years the quality of that traffic has deteriorated and the cost per sold unit has skyrocketed. The fact that every single dealership in your market is competing for the same set of eyeballs has not helped the situation. Now that sales have slowed down it’s time to take a deeper look into those AdWords budgets.

PCG’s research has shown that around 80% of the Google AdWords traffic being driven to dealership websites are people simply searching for the name of the dealership. People who would have searched you out anyway, so there is no need to pay for their click. Basically, an overpriced Yellow Pages directory for your dealership.

Now add in the Bot traffic and Service traffic and you are left with very few sales opportunities from your AdWords budget. You can easily analyze what is being generated by putting VistaDash on your website to monitor engagement and isolate bot traffic. You can use a service like CallRevu to score your phone calls as Sales/Service.

Once you start to analyze your AdWords traffic deeper, you will quickly realize that you are left with very few sales opportunities. The ones you do have are usually looking for the lowest price and they expect you to lose money on them when you sell them a vehicle. You’ve been told that you must be on Google. Google is the, be all, end all of digital marketing. The majority of most dealership’s digital spend is with Google. You’ve been told that is where people go to shop for a car. What are you supposed to do?

The answer is right in front of you. Most of you are on it multiple times throughout the day. Facebook! When Facebook entered the market place there was a lot of snake oil being sold. Vendors telling you they could increase sales for $500-$1,000 a month by setting up a Facebook page, generating some Fans/Likes and starting to posting some cool engaging content. It was supposed to be a cheap and easy way of selling more cars.

I was one of the first vendors to jump on the bandwagon. I shifted my attention from direct mail to Facebook marketing. I spent 8 years trying to find the right formula to help dealers sell more cars for less. The industry and myself approached this in the wrong way. Remember, nothing in life worth having is Free or Easy!

We changed everything we knew about marketing. We’ve even been told that you "don’t sell cars on social" that you were supposed to post engaging content that may not even be related to your business. Vendors and dealers did this because they were trying to fight the ever changing algorithms that Facebook implemented to reduce the amount of spam content their user base was exposed to. That, and they wanted to push marketers to a Pay-to-Play strategy so they could increase their bottom line.

Over the past year our clients have taken a different approach. Many of our clients have invested in "paid" Facebook ads and shifted large portions of their budgets over from Google to Facebook. Facebook released something called Lead Gen Ads about a year ago. It finally gave us a way to generate large volumes of leads from paid ads.

These ads combined with the right response mechanisms showed us that these are real people looking to talk business about buying a car. Many of which are not in market when they see the ad on Facebook, giving the dealership first crack at the consumer’s business, not having to compete with every other dealer in town.

In February John Carlson, the General Manager at Frank Hyundai, spent $10,000 on paid Facebook advertising. Much of this budget was reallocated from Google AdWords. They went from generating clicks with a low conversion and few new sales opportunities to over 500 people text messaging them about buying a car. They have drastically increased sales and their overall gross on each unit sold. They are reaching customers in ways their competition isn’t. This gives them the advantage they need to dominate their market.

If you feel like it’s time to take a deeper look at your AdWords campaigns but don’t know where to start, text "AdWords" to (855) 614-8080 and one of our team members would be happy to help you analyze your AdWords spend.